This is Not my Beautiful Chart
15 Apr 2011The only thing good about this infographic is the title. Massive dot pie chart? Ick. Color selection? Ick ick. And since you have to read the text and numbers for any kind of comprehension to take place, why bother with the pies at all? Man, I’m grumpy today.
Comment Form
What is Chart Porn?
An addictive collection of beautiful charts, graphs, maps, and interactive data visualization toys -- on topics from around the world.
Categories
- Bailout (118)
- Chartporn Related (3)
- Commentary (21)
- Culture (669)
- Emerging Markets (66)
- Employment (245)
- Environment/weather (133)
- Finance (298)
- Food (92)
- Global Economy (373)
- Graphic Design (bad) (26)
- Graphic Design (general) (183)
- Graphic Tools (23)
- History (158)
- Housing (162)
- Humor (204)
- Innovative (183)
- Interactive (545)
- Internet/tech (96)
- Maps (577)
- News Media (34)
- Politics (329)
- Reference (97)
- Science (331)
- Source: Economist (101)
- Source: FT (92)
- Source: NYT (147)
- Source: Ritholtz (76)
- Source: USA Today (27)
- Source: Washington Post (90)
- Source: WSJ (135)
- Sports (58)
- Stock Market (74)
- Uncategorized (2)
- Updated regularly (76)
- US Economy (553)
- Video (22)
- J S: Thanks for the great story. Miss reading this blog. Hope to see you more active again. [...]
- jake: I lived in a DC row house for 6 years, and I'm writing this comment from my tiny 1 bedroom apartment [...]
- ronny pettersen: Hilarious and unfortunately accurate... ;-) [...]
- Jeremy: The screen usually gets larger for every phone, even though the size of the device itself follows th [...]
- noah g: I would like to use the graph for a debate, may I have the source you used to get it because i feel [...]
7 Responses to This is Not my Beautiful Chart
Bo
April 15th, 2011 at 4:08 pm
I thought porn was explicit images that are created for excitement and satisfaction?
David
April 15th, 2011 at 10:00 pm
Well, the data is also interesting. The big chart in the center is not too bad, but I see what you meant: he put aesthetics before usability with the smaller pie charts.
Scott
April 17th, 2011 at 6:31 am
I don’t know, the dot pie chart seems to be the traditional way to show party affiliation in legislatures. But saying that 44% of the population is Democrat is pretty outdated… Currently, Democrats are at about 35%, Republicans at 34%. Unless the chart itself is really old, I can’t think of any good reason to have Democrats so high, unless the goal is to mislead your readers.
Matt
April 19th, 2011 at 3:20 pm
Talk about viewing the world through race/gender/creed lenses.
“I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character.”
White men have dominated because of the wealth and influence they brought over from Europe. But as our current president demonstrated, wealth and skin color don’t mean jack when people want change.
Raphael
May 5th, 2011 at 1:51 pm
I disagree–the red/blue color choice is harldy arbitrary. Anything besides that would be misleading.
The other colors? Well, maybe you can criticize that. Using browns for races and pink/blue for gender is kind of groan-worthy.
And one dot to equal one representative–that’s pretty effective.
I think the message is pretty obvious, without the text: The two distributions are way different.
cole
June 24th, 2011 at 12:40 am
Wow, I’ve longed wished death to pie charts (our eyes do not to a good job of attributing quantitative values to 2D spaces. In plain english: pie charts are really hard for people to read!). But this dot-donut thing is perhaps even worse! I also agree with your ick-ick classification of the chosen color scheme.
john
November 24th, 2011 at 6:13 am
i like the way you represented the data in the dotted pie. I have a query regarding the filling of each dots in pie, How you have filled this dots in pie?
As i am a software developer i want know is there any alogorithm to fill the dots in pie ??