Improving on Minard?!?

In: Graphic Design (general) History Innovative Maps

2 Mar 2012

How dare they! Well, actually, it’s a fun exercise. Declared by Tufte to be one of the best statistical graphics ever drawn, Joseph Minard’s graph of Napoleon’s march on Russia is definitely a classic (a copy hangs in my bathroom).

image

John Boykin recently took a crack at redesigning the classic, and goes into quite a bit of detail on his website about the choices he made:

image

John links to a series of other re-creations and re-interpretations of Minard’s dataset, as collected by Michael Friendly:

image image

3D:

image

I particularly like this googlemap version:

image

And then there’s the executive summary version. Bwahahahahaha!

image

(via JunkCharts)

flattr this!

1 Response to Improving on Minard?!?

Avatar

Al

March 2nd, 2012 at 1:10 pm

I love how it’s the last one that is the most powerful…

Comment Form


blog advertising
is good for you

What is Chart Porn?

An addictive collection of beautiful charts, graphs, maps, and interactive data visualization toys -- on topics from around the world.

  • Rogier: True as long as the task at hand doesn't change.... [...]
  • Jay: The Geek looses. Management eventually realizes it can automate his job. [...]
  • Frank: @ Michael: apparently you live somewhere *within* the big, brown sphere. I live on the surface of [...]
  • neale: Thanks made my day :-) [...]
  • Dust: Yep, the 3d does make it confusing. The label should read "area of circles = GDP in USD) [...]